Attempt to determine the legal nature of the concept of proper (improper) method of protection and the hypothesis of place in legal doctrine
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.17308/law/1995-5502/2026/2/60-77Keywords:
appropriate remedy, inappropriate remedy, legal precedents, definition, way of legal regulation, methodAbstract
The article attempts to define the legal nature of the phenomenon such as «appropriate» (even as «inappropriate») remedy, as well as its place in the hierarchy of legal regulation of civil procedure social relation. The absence of legal definition or statutory or defined criteria for the assessment of remedy not only doesn’t make easier but also makes judicial defense more difficult, entrenches in the public consciousness narratives of unpredictability and inconsistency of legal precedents. The proposed definition of «appropriate» remedy as special civil method of legal regulation of civil procedure law and identification of modes of its action presents a contour of fully viable conception.
Downloads
References
Alekseev S. S. Ascension to law. Searches and solutions. Moscow : Norm, 2001. 752 p.
Alekseev S. S. General theory of law : textbook. 2nd ed. Moscow : Velbi : Prospect, 2008. 565 p.
Alekseev S. S. Property law : problems of theory. Moscow : Norm, 2000. 238 p.
Arbitration process : textbook / A. V. Absalyamov, D. B. Abushenko, K. L. Branovitsky [et al.] ; ed. by V.V.Yarkov. 7th ed., revised and add. Moscow : Statute, 2017.
Arbitration process : textbook / ed. by Doctor of Legal Sciences, Professor V. V. Yarkov. 10th ed., revised and additional Moscow : Statute, 2025. 830 p.
Bocharov V. A., Markin V. I. Introduction to logic : textbook. Moscow : INFO-FORUM : INFRA-M, 2010. 560 p.
Braginsky M. I., Vitriansky V. V. Contract law. Book one. 3rd ed. Moscow : Statut, 2011. 848 p.
Civil procedure : textbook / ed. by M. K. Treushnikov. 4th ed., revised and additional. Moscow, 2011.
Civil law ways to protect the ownership of real estate : scientific and practical handbook on the application of civil legislation / under the general editorship of V. N. Solovyov. 3rd ed., revised and additional Moscow : Yurait, 2014. 458 p.
De Bono E. Six hats of thinking : translated from English. 4th ed. Moscow : Mann, Ivanov and Ferber, 2016. 224 p.
Didenko A. A. Judicial practice as a source of civil law // Scientific journal of KubGAU. 2015. No. 112(08). 12 p.
Zhuykov V. M. On the issue of judicial practice as a source of law // Judicial practice as a source of law. Moscow, 2000. P. 78–90.
Ivin I. I. The art of thinking correctly. Moscow : Prospect, 2019. 193 p. + 304 p.
Koval V. N. Some aspects of defining means of protecting property rights in real estate // Bulletin of civil process. 2021. No. 1. P. 243–264.
Komolov A. L. Finis sanctificat media, or The return of property to good faith purchaser // Court administrator. 2021. No. 3. P. 28.
Krasnova S. A. Theoretical foundations of classification of civil law means of protection // Russian legal journal. 2011. No. 2. P. 170–176.
Kuznetsova O. A. Improper means of protecting civil rights as a basis for fi ling a claim // Bulletin of Perm University. Legal Sciences. 2010. No. 4. P. 116–121.
Latypov D. N. System of means of protecting civil rights in the Russian Federation : dr. legal sci. dis. Perm, 2022. 482 p.
Lomidze O. G., Lomidze E. Yu. Principles of applying means of protecting violated rights // Law. 2013. No. 8. P. 128–137.
Muratova D. A. The legal nature of means of protecting civil rights // Russian Justice. 2009. No. 4. P. 16–20.
Muromtsev S. A. Civil law of Ancient Rome : lectures by Sergey Muromtsev. Moscow : A. I. Mamontov & Co. Printing House, 1883. XXXV + 697 p.
Muromtsev S. A. Selected works. Moscow : ROSSPEN, 2010. 599 p.
Nazimov I. A. Restoration of the situation that exis ted before the violation of law as a civil law category // Russian legal magazine : electronic application. 2014. No. 6. P. 34–41. URL: cyberleninka.ru
Osintsev D. V. Methods of legal regulation or means of formulating legal norms? // Russian legal journal. 2016. No. 6. P. 153–160.
Perelman H., Olbrechts-Tyteca L. From the book «The new rhetoric : a treatise on argumentation» / transl. from French by T. L. Vetoshkina // Language and modeling of social interaction : translations / ed. by V. M. Sergeyev and P. B. Parshin ; general ed. V. V. Petrova. Moscow : Progress, 1987. 710 p.
Sazanova I. V. The claim for recognition of registered rights (encumbrances) as nonexistent : place in the system of means of civil rights protection // Lawyer. 2021. No. 10. P. 14–20.
Solovyeva V. N. Civil law means of protecting property rights in real estate : scientific and practical guide to applying civil legislation / A. V. Zarubin [and others] ; under general editorship of V. N. Solovyev. 3rd ed., revised and supplemented. Moscow : Yurait Publishing, 2014. 458 p.
Sukhanov E. I. Problems of reforming property law // Law, 2018. No. 12. P. 46–52.
Teryayevsky S. A. System of methods of legal regulation in the legal practice of the modern Russian state : cand. legal sci. dis. abstr. Saratov, 2009. 30 p.
Fedosyuk A. P. Means of protecting civil rights // Foundations of state and law. 2003. No. 5. P. 66–70.
Yakovlev V. F. Civil law method of regulating social relations : textbook. Sverdlovsk : Publishing house of Sverdlovsk Law Institute, 1972. 210 p.
