Манипулирование юридическими целями и средствами в процессе толкования права: понятие, содержание, технологии
Ключевые слова:
манипулирование, юридическая цель, юридическое средство, правовое регулирование, толкование права, правотворчество, реализация права, интерес
Аннотация
Поднимается проблема манипулирования юридическими целями и средствами в правоинтерпретационном процессе – широко распространенная, но практически не исследованная в отечественной юриспруденции форма правомерного поведения. Аргументируется позиция, согласно которой манипулирование юридическими целями и средствами имманентно правовому регулированию общественных отношений в целом и толкованию права в частности. На конкретных примерах раскрываются содержание, специфика и технологии манипулирования юридическими целями и средствами в правоинтерпретационном процессе, а также его влияние на правотворчество и реализацию права.
Скачивания
Данные скачивания пока не доступны.
Литература
1. Bagmet A. M., Perov V. A. On the issue of improving legislation in the field of procurement of goods, works, services to ensure state and municipal needs // Civil law. 2019. No 5. P. 38–41.
2. Belsky K. S., Pavlova E. Yu. To the question of the interpretation of the norms of financial law // Financial law. 2020. No 3. P. 3–9.
3. Vlasenko N. A., Zaloilo M. V. Concretization and interpretation of law as a creative content of judicial practice // Journal of Russian Law. 2016. No 8. P. 43–57.
4. Voplenko N. N. Types and acts of official interpretation of law // Leningrad juridical journal. 2008. No 2 (12). Р. 29–54.
5. Voplenko N. N. Interpretation of law. Volgograd, 2007. 122 p.
6. Goncharov I. V. Interaction of the Russian Federation with international institutions in the field of human rights: current state and development trends // Journal of Russian Law. 2021. No 9. P. 119–132.
7. Goncharova A. A. Problems of determining the legal regime of land plots privatized in the framework of the land reform of the 90s, in the division of property of spouses // Family and housing law. 2021. No 6. P. 3–7.
8. Dotsenko E. L. Psychology of manipulation: phenomena, mechanisms and protection. M. : MGU Publishing House, 1997. 342 p.
9. Ershov V. V. Legal and individual regulation of public relations. M. : RGUP, 2018. 627 p.
10. Zaloilo M. V. Concretization and interpretation of legal norms: problems of correlation and interaction // Journal of Russian Law. 2010. No 5. P. 105–112.
11. Zykov S. V. Teleological interpretation of the category «exclusive right» // Actual problems of Russian law. 2021. No 4. P. 94–100.
12. Ispolinov A. S. Legal status of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (to the 70th anniversary of adoption) // Comparative Constitutional Review. 2018. No 4. P. 100–107.
13. Karimov B. R. Federal territories in the Russian Federation: the first experience of creating and problems of constitutional and legal regulation // Constitutional and municipal law. 2022. No 3. P. 51–58.
14. Koval V. N. Influence of the concept of the spirit of laws on the development of modern civil material, as well as civil and arbitration procedural law // Bulletin of the civil process. 2022. No 1. P. 23–39.
15. Kovler A. I. European convention: problems of interpretation and implementation. M. : IZiSP : Norma : INFRA-M, 2019. 400 p.
16. Kolosova N. M. To the question of the legal responsibility of a senator of the Russian Federation and a deputy of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation // Justice. 2021. No 3/4. P. 58–62.
17. Malko A. V., Subochev V. V. Legitimate interests in the legal life of society: topical issues of theory and practice // News of higher educational institutions. Jurisprudence. 2014. No 2 (313). P. 84–98.
18. Marchenko M. N. The Constitutional Court as a subject of political relations // Srednerusskiy vestnik obshchestvennykh nauk. 2008. No 1 (6). P. 56–63.
19. Matuzov N. I., Malko A. V. Theory of state and law: textbook. 5th edition. M. : Delo Publishing House, RANEPA, 2021. 528 p.
20. Nadezhdin G. N. Doctrinal interpretation of the law: abstract. dis. ... cand. legal sciences. N. Novgorod, 2005. 25 p.
21. Potapenko E. G. Defects in the interpretation of the rules of arbitration procedural law in modern judicial practice // Russian judge. 2020. No 12. P. 15–19.
22. Psychological aspects of destructive information-psychological impact / A. M. Stolyarenko [et al.] // Psychology and Law. 2019. Vol. 9, No 4. P. 75–89.
23. Rogova E. V., Zabavko R. A. Application by the defender of the norm establishing responsibility for illegal hunting // Advocate practice. 2018. No 4. P. 15–20.
24. Sinyakin I. I., Skuratova A. Yu. Norms of jus cogens: historical aspect and modern significance for international law // Bulletin of the Perm University. Legal Sciences. 2018. No 3. P. 526–545.
25. Starilov Yu. N. Expediency or legality: what criterion is better for the practice of forming a system of federal executive bodies? // Administrative law and process. 2017. No 3. P. 24–32.
26. Subochev V. V. Dialectics of the interests of the individual, society and the state as a general legal problem // Law and State: Theory and Practice. 2006. No 5. P. 125–135.
27. Subochev V. V. The mechanism of transformation of legitimate interests into subjective rights and subjective rights into legitimate interests // Modern law. 2007. No 3. P. 89–96.
28. Subochev V. V. Political and legal manipulation as the basis for the governance of society in the era of post-truth // Tomsk State University Journal of Law 2019. No 34. P. 29–43.
29. Fedotova Yu. E. Insulting religious feelings of believers and criminal law: work on mistakes // Legal Science and Law Enforcement Practice. 2016. No 1 (35). P. 199–205.
30. Fokina M. A. Abuse of procedural rights: the relationship between the spirit and the letter of the law // Bulletin of the civil process. 2022. No 1. P. 48–62.
31. Tumanova L. V. Definition of the law to be applied, taking into account its letter and spirit // Bulletin of the civil process. 2022. No 1. P. 40–47.
32. Cherdantsev A. F. Interpretation of law and contracts. M. : Unity, 2003. 381 p.
33. Goodin R. E. Manipulatory Politics. New York, 1982. 250 p.
34. Sirazetdinova M., Stoletov A., Lukmanova R. Manipulation, Individuation, and the Self. Cogito. 2021. 13 (4). P. 103–123. URL
2. Belsky K. S., Pavlova E. Yu. To the question of the interpretation of the norms of financial law // Financial law. 2020. No 3. P. 3–9.
3. Vlasenko N. A., Zaloilo M. V. Concretization and interpretation of law as a creative content of judicial practice // Journal of Russian Law. 2016. No 8. P. 43–57.
4. Voplenko N. N. Types and acts of official interpretation of law // Leningrad juridical journal. 2008. No 2 (12). Р. 29–54.
5. Voplenko N. N. Interpretation of law. Volgograd, 2007. 122 p.
6. Goncharov I. V. Interaction of the Russian Federation with international institutions in the field of human rights: current state and development trends // Journal of Russian Law. 2021. No 9. P. 119–132.
7. Goncharova A. A. Problems of determining the legal regime of land plots privatized in the framework of the land reform of the 90s, in the division of property of spouses // Family and housing law. 2021. No 6. P. 3–7.
8. Dotsenko E. L. Psychology of manipulation: phenomena, mechanisms and protection. M. : MGU Publishing House, 1997. 342 p.
9. Ershov V. V. Legal and individual regulation of public relations. M. : RGUP, 2018. 627 p.
10. Zaloilo M. V. Concretization and interpretation of legal norms: problems of correlation and interaction // Journal of Russian Law. 2010. No 5. P. 105–112.
11. Zykov S. V. Teleological interpretation of the category «exclusive right» // Actual problems of Russian law. 2021. No 4. P. 94–100.
12. Ispolinov A. S. Legal status of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (to the 70th anniversary of adoption) // Comparative Constitutional Review. 2018. No 4. P. 100–107.
13. Karimov B. R. Federal territories in the Russian Federation: the first experience of creating and problems of constitutional and legal regulation // Constitutional and municipal law. 2022. No 3. P. 51–58.
14. Koval V. N. Influence of the concept of the spirit of laws on the development of modern civil material, as well as civil and arbitration procedural law // Bulletin of the civil process. 2022. No 1. P. 23–39.
15. Kovler A. I. European convention: problems of interpretation and implementation. M. : IZiSP : Norma : INFRA-M, 2019. 400 p.
16. Kolosova N. M. To the question of the legal responsibility of a senator of the Russian Federation and a deputy of the State Duma of the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation // Justice. 2021. No 3/4. P. 58–62.
17. Malko A. V., Subochev V. V. Legitimate interests in the legal life of society: topical issues of theory and practice // News of higher educational institutions. Jurisprudence. 2014. No 2 (313). P. 84–98.
18. Marchenko M. N. The Constitutional Court as a subject of political relations // Srednerusskiy vestnik obshchestvennykh nauk. 2008. No 1 (6). P. 56–63.
19. Matuzov N. I., Malko A. V. Theory of state and law: textbook. 5th edition. M. : Delo Publishing House, RANEPA, 2021. 528 p.
20. Nadezhdin G. N. Doctrinal interpretation of the law: abstract. dis. ... cand. legal sciences. N. Novgorod, 2005. 25 p.
21. Potapenko E. G. Defects in the interpretation of the rules of arbitration procedural law in modern judicial practice // Russian judge. 2020. No 12. P. 15–19.
22. Psychological aspects of destructive information-psychological impact / A. M. Stolyarenko [et al.] // Psychology and Law. 2019. Vol. 9, No 4. P. 75–89.
23. Rogova E. V., Zabavko R. A. Application by the defender of the norm establishing responsibility for illegal hunting // Advocate practice. 2018. No 4. P. 15–20.
24. Sinyakin I. I., Skuratova A. Yu. Norms of jus cogens: historical aspect and modern significance for international law // Bulletin of the Perm University. Legal Sciences. 2018. No 3. P. 526–545.
25. Starilov Yu. N. Expediency or legality: what criterion is better for the practice of forming a system of federal executive bodies? // Administrative law and process. 2017. No 3. P. 24–32.
26. Subochev V. V. Dialectics of the interests of the individual, society and the state as a general legal problem // Law and State: Theory and Practice. 2006. No 5. P. 125–135.
27. Subochev V. V. The mechanism of transformation of legitimate interests into subjective rights and subjective rights into legitimate interests // Modern law. 2007. No 3. P. 89–96.
28. Subochev V. V. Political and legal manipulation as the basis for the governance of society in the era of post-truth // Tomsk State University Journal of Law 2019. No 34. P. 29–43.
29. Fedotova Yu. E. Insulting religious feelings of believers and criminal law: work on mistakes // Legal Science and Law Enforcement Practice. 2016. No 1 (35). P. 199–205.
30. Fokina M. A. Abuse of procedural rights: the relationship between the spirit and the letter of the law // Bulletin of the civil process. 2022. No 1. P. 48–62.
31. Tumanova L. V. Definition of the law to be applied, taking into account its letter and spirit // Bulletin of the civil process. 2022. No 1. P. 40–47.
32. Cherdantsev A. F. Interpretation of law and contracts. M. : Unity, 2003. 381 p.
33. Goodin R. E. Manipulatory Politics. New York, 1982. 250 p.
34. Sirazetdinova M., Stoletov A., Lukmanova R. Manipulation, Individuation, and the Self. Cogito. 2021. 13 (4). P. 103–123. URL
Опубликован
2022-12-26
Раздел
Теория и история государства и права
