Статус залогодержателя корпоративных прав: доказательство существования нового ограниченного вещного права или пространное толкование статьи 358.15 Гражданского кодекса Российской Федерации?
Ключевые слова:
залог корпоративных прав, осуществление залогодержателем корпоративных прав, правоспособность залогодателя
Аннотация
Анализируется судебная практика по вопросу осуществления залогодержателем прав участника общества. Сделан вывод, что суды практически всегда отказывают в защите прав залогодателей от действий залогодержателя исключительно со ссылкой на возможность их осуществления последним. Приведено обоснование того, что такой подход не способствует сохранению баланса интересов сторон залоговых правоотношений. Сформулирован вывод о том, что возможность осуществления корпоративных прав не создает у залогодержателя в отношении них «временной собственности».
Скачивания
Данные скачивания пока не доступны.
Литература
Bevzenko R. S. Proprietary security as a mechanism for control and management of the debtor's assets // Civil Law Review. 2018. No. 1. P. 10–22.
Drobnig U., Boger O. Proprietary Security in Movable Assets // Sellier European Law Publishers, 2015. 934 p.
Egorov A. V., Usmanova E. R. Pledge and title security : theoretical and practical comparison of structures // Civil Law Review. 2014. No. 4. P. 56–127.
Gribanov V. P. Exercise and protection of civil rights. Moscow : Statut, 2001. 411 р.
Kanashevskiy V. A. Offshore companies and trusts. Anti-offshore regulation. Moscow : Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2018. 303 p.
Laptev V. A. Corporate law : legal organization of corporate systems : monograph. Moscow : Prospekt, 2019. 384 p.
Makovskaya A. A. Major and related party transactions: analysis and commentary on the Laws "On Joint Stock Companies" and "On Limited Liability Companies. Moscow : Statut, 2020. 375 p.
Mukhamadeeva R. A. Pledge of the rights of participants in a legal entity: features of the exercise of corporate rights by the pledger // Civil Law. 2019. No.3. P. 36–38.
Sukhanov E. A. On trust management of property as a legal method of exercising ownership // The Herald of Economic Justice. 2017. No. 11. P. 44–56.
Usmanova E. R. Title security of civil obligations : cand legal sci. diss. Moscow, 2018. 152 p.
Vasilevskaya L. Yu. Pledge of Rights of Members of Legal Entities: Issues and Contradictions // Civil Law. 2018. No. 1. Р. 3–6.
Volchanskiy M. A. Consequences of violation by the debtor of the pledger of the obligation to fulfill the pledged claim in favor of the pledgee (clause 3 of article 358.6 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation // The Herald of Economic Justice. 2020. No. 6. P. 79–99.
Wood Ph. R. Comparative Law of Security Interests and Title Finance. 2nd ed. Sweet & Maxwell, 2007. 933 p.
Drobnig U., Boger O. Proprietary Security in Movable Assets // Sellier European Law Publishers, 2015. 934 p.
Egorov A. V., Usmanova E. R. Pledge and title security : theoretical and practical comparison of structures // Civil Law Review. 2014. No. 4. P. 56–127.
Gribanov V. P. Exercise and protection of civil rights. Moscow : Statut, 2001. 411 р.
Kanashevskiy V. A. Offshore companies and trusts. Anti-offshore regulation. Moscow : Mezhdunarodnye otnosheniya, 2018. 303 p.
Laptev V. A. Corporate law : legal organization of corporate systems : monograph. Moscow : Prospekt, 2019. 384 p.
Makovskaya A. A. Major and related party transactions: analysis and commentary on the Laws "On Joint Stock Companies" and "On Limited Liability Companies. Moscow : Statut, 2020. 375 p.
Mukhamadeeva R. A. Pledge of the rights of participants in a legal entity: features of the exercise of corporate rights by the pledger // Civil Law. 2019. No.3. P. 36–38.
Sukhanov E. A. On trust management of property as a legal method of exercising ownership // The Herald of Economic Justice. 2017. No. 11. P. 44–56.
Usmanova E. R. Title security of civil obligations : cand legal sci. diss. Moscow, 2018. 152 p.
Vasilevskaya L. Yu. Pledge of Rights of Members of Legal Entities: Issues and Contradictions // Civil Law. 2018. No. 1. Р. 3–6.
Volchanskiy M. A. Consequences of violation by the debtor of the pledger of the obligation to fulfill the pledged claim in favor of the pledgee (clause 3 of article 358.6 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation // The Herald of Economic Justice. 2020. No. 6. P. 79–99.
Wood Ph. R. Comparative Law of Security Interests and Title Finance. 2nd ed. Sweet & Maxwell, 2007. 933 p.
Опубликован
2024-04-02
Раздел
Гражданское право и гражданский процесс
