Challenges and development pathways for the expert examination of grants

Keywords: grants, applications, expert, artificial intelligence, grant financing


Introduction. Organisational and methodological aspects of the examination of applications submitted for grants provided by Russian scientific foundations.
Purpose. To determine the role of artificial intelligence in the system for the selection of grant applications. To study methods of project analysis currently used by experts and to develop an innovative algorithm for the verification of applications.
Methods. The study used data from the Ministry of Finance of the Russian Federation, the National Audit Office, information provided by Russian scientific foundations (Russian Foundation for Basic Research and Russian Science Foundation), and other data related to the regulation of grant funding. The methods of the investigation included analysis, observation, generalisation, comparison, grouping, etc.
Results. A critical analysis of the multicomponent structure of the application procedure was carried out. Methods for the expert support of projects were identified. A conceptual model of a hybrid method for assessing grant applications was developed. The completeness and versatility requirements to the inspected projects were determined.
Conclusions. The hypothesis was confirmed that it is necessary to apply an innovative approach to expert examinations, which ensures the effectiveness of controlling applications at various stages of their life cycle.


Metrics Loading ...

Author Biography

Ekaterina Yu. Bubnova, Voronezh State University

Postgraduate Student. Department of Economic Analysis and Audit.


Babina, K. I. (2014) Legal problems of ensuring information transpar-ency in obtaining grants by scientific institutions. Scientific and Practical Journal. Information security of regions. 1 (14), 89-91. (In Russian).

Belyavsky, O. V. (2018) Scientific and educational organizations as participants in grant legal relations. Education and Law. 9, 237-244. (In Russian).

Bibarov-Gosudarev, A. P. (2019) The concept and essence of a grant in civil law. 25 years of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation: traditions and innovations of private law development: traditions and innovations of private law development: materials of the international. scientific-practical. conf. Tambov, Print Service, pp. 257-263. (In Russian)

Bubnova, E.Yu. (2021) Features of obtaining grants by higher educa-tional institutions. Actual problems of finance, money circulation and credit: mate-rials of the national conference dedicated to the 25th anniversary of the Depart-ment of Finance and Credit of the Voronezh State Agrarian University named after Emperor Peter I. September 2021, Voronezh, pp. 96-100. (In Russian)

Bubnova, E.Yu. (2021) The system of scientific grants in the Russian Federation. Management of innovative development of agro-food systems at the national and regional levels: materials of the III International scientific and practical conference. October 27-28, Voronezh, pp. 218-221. (In Russian)

Gataullin, T. M., Nikolotova, S. V. & Goncharov, L. L. (2016) Model of work of the grant fund. Bulletin of the University. 2, 206-209 (In Russian)

Erokhina, E. (2019) Subsidy or grant. Lawyer of the university. 2, 39-40 (In Russian)

Ivantsova, S. N. (2019) Grants. Additional support. Budget account-ing. 1, 36-41(In Russian)

Kaminskaya, E. V. & Rudchenko, T. L. (2018) Grants: concept, legal support, features of implementation and classification of types. Bulletin of the Sa-ratov State Law Academy. 3 (122), 255-263 (In Russian)

Medvedev, Yu. (2021) How Russian science will be financed. Ros-siyskaya Gazeta. Federal release. 284 (8635) (In Russian)

Sirotkin, A. V. & Starikova, O. A. (2019) Sectoral identification of applications in an automated expert system for distributing grants. Modern science-intensive technologies. 7, 99-10 (In Russian)

Storozheva, A. N. (2020) On the issue of the procedure for filing, reg-istration and consideration of applications for participation in the competition of the Presidential Grants Fund. Science and education: experience, problems, devel-opment prospects: materials of the international scientific and practical confer-ence. April 21-23, Krasnoyarsk Part 2. Krasnoyarsk: Krasnoyarsk State Agrarian University, pp. 600-604 (In Russian)

Tatarinova, S. M. (2014) Japan: the system of state support for the de-velopment of science. Polis. Political studies. 1, 166-174 (In Russian) DOI: 10.17976/jpps/2014.01.12

Besselaar, P. (2018) Studying grant decision-making: a linguistic analysis of review reports. Scientometrics. 117, 313–329

Hug, S. E. & Aeschbach, M. (2020) Criteria for assessing grant appli-cations: a systematic review. Nature Palgrave Communications. 6, 37 DOI: 10.1057/s41599-020-0412-9

Matzler, P. P. (2021) Grant proposal abstracts in science and engineer-ing: A prototypical move-structure pattern and its variations. Journal of English for Academic Purposes. 49, 100938. DOI:10.1016/j.jeap.2020.100938

Patil, S. G. (2019) How to plan and write a budget for research grant pro-posal? Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine. 10(2), 139-142. DOI: 10.1016/j.jaim.2017.08.005

Yousoubova, L. & McAlpine, L. (2021) Why is the proposal alone not suffi-cient for grant success? Building research fundability through collaborative re-search networking. Innovations in Education and Teaching International. 02, 93 – 103. DOI:10.1080/14703297.2021.1997784

How to Cite
Bubnova, E. Y. (2022). Challenges and development pathways for the expert examination of grants. Proceedings of Voronezh State University. Series: Economics and Management, (2), 112-122.
Finance, Monetary Circulation and Credit